Onder andere met: Nicolas Cage (John Koestler), Chandler Canterbury (Caleb Koestler), Rose Byrne (Diana), Lara Robinson (Abby / Lucinda), D.G. Maloney (The Stranger), Nadia Townsend (Grace), Alan Hopgood (Reverend Koestler), Adrienne Pickering (Allison), Joshua Long (Younger Caleb), Danielle Carter (Miss Taylor (1959)), Alethea McGrath (Miss Taylor (2009)), David Lennie (Principal Clark (1959)), Tamara Donnellan (Lucinda's Mother), Travis Waite (Lucinda's Father), Ben Mendelsohn (Phil Beckman)